The best editing advice anyone accidentally gave me

A year or two ago, a professor of mine was editing a novel he’d written and posted, on Facebook, an analogy that has significantly influenced the way I edit. I can’t remember his exact phrasing (and I wish I could, because that was half the impact of it), but the gist of the comparison was that sometimes, a story has pieces to it that are interesting or well-written or the result of hours of thought and work, but simply — if an editor is being completely honest — don’t belong in that story. Like puppies, those pieces are good things, and you’d never want to part with them, but if they are unnecessary, they have to go. Chop the piece, kill the puppy.

Writing produced by college students is often filled with puppies, because college students are very good at finding good things, but not always very good at knowing whether that good thing is actually essential to their work. Because I work at my school’s Writing Center and am senior copy editor for our magazine, I encounter puppies on a daily basis. There was a time when I would have been too taken with the quality of the writing or the interestingness of the information to recognize those things as superfluous. But now, I am merciless. I steel myself and kill the puppy. It’s a painful, unpleasant, and sometimes guilt-inducing process, but the end result — a tight, polished, graceful piece of writing — confirms that being merciless was the right thing to do.

Because I need a little consolation, here’s a picture of a puppy I would never kill.

The best editing advice anyone accidentally gave me

5 thoughts on “The best editing advice anyone accidentally gave me

  1. Great advice…and, yes, I am afraid I tend to keep the puppies at times. I suppose it helps to remember the perhaps we can always find another home – another story – for those ousted puppies, somewhere down the line. At least that’s what I’ll tell myself next time I have to do the deed;-)

    1. I suppose that depends on what you mean by “best.” Best-written? If so, that probably means the whole piece needs to be worked on — but being well-written doesn’t mean it’s necessary to the overall focus, which is the point.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s